Best Canceled TV Shows

8. Angel

Ahh, one of my favorites, and the longest running show of this list. Angel was cancelled after 5 seasons. Which may sound like a lot, but unfortunately the show had it’s best season on it’s last. Fresh off of Buffy and Firefly, Angel‘s creator Joss Whedon, came back to the show and you could really tell the difference.  By Angel‘s fifth season he had joined his nemesis, the evil law firm Wolfram & Hart. Trying to turn things around from within the evil corporation we see all new sides to Angel and his crew. Unfortunately, Whedon was not informed soon enough of the cancellation and it ends on a major cliffhanger. The apocalypse to be exact….

What Happened? Despite being on of the WB’s highest rated programs at the time, it was canceled. Many people were surprised about it, most of all people involved with the show. The current season had enjoyed it’s critical best, and things were starting to pick up. Head writer at the time believes that because they asked for an early pick up they were dropped. Luckily there is hope in some form. While David Boreanaz has moved over to “Bones”, he can still exist the same way in comic book form. Last year Angel: After the Fall came out in comic book form. It is an official continuation of Angel and uses the plot Season 6 would have had.

7. Carnivale

A classic good vs. evil story. Carnivale focused on two main characters, Ben Hawkins, a person who possess unexplained abilities to heal. The other main character, is a Methodist preacher named Justin Crowe who has the ability control people and turn their sins against them in terrifying manners. Taking place in the Dust Bowl era, we are shown the life of Ben Hawkins in the traveling Carnival he joins. The show was known for its sweeping mythology. It was a show that was much more than it appeared.

What Happened? Well, it was expensive. HBO couldn’t justify the costs anymore, even though it had good ratings for an HBO show. Offers were made, but lowering the budget with such a large cast and a period setting was just not doable. The viewership was very loyal and ran a huge campaign to the network, but to no avail. Much of the story was left open ended. Creator, Daniel Knauf, has come out and revealed details of the mythology to satisfy viewers who were left hanging.

6.Dead Like Me

Don’t you hate it when you are killed by a flaming toilet seat from a space station? George Lass did, however it did give her full-time employment as a Reaper. Dead Like Me‘s apathetic George is made to interview for a job by her over-bearing mother. When outside she is killed by a toilet seat from the heavens. She is then given a new body (sort of) and becomes of a Reaper. Her job is to take a soul before they die, so they don’t have to suffer. The cast was great all around and the chemistry between Mandy Patinkin’s Rube and Ellen Muth’s George is great. It’s filled with many rich characters and for a show about death, really fun to watch.

What Happened? Bryan Fuller, the brains behind the show, left early in the first season due to disagreements with the studio. He set up a decent guideline to start from, but without his influence there is a bit of a drop in the second season. Despite rumors that the show was doing very well in viewers, Showtime canned it. They have recently come out with a DVD that continued the arc of the show. However, one of the main characters is missing, and the other is replaced by another actress. It was fun to see the show again, but it didn’t feel the same.

Page: 1 2 3 4 5

Blake Fehl

Member of the St. Louis Film Critics Association. Co-Founder of Saint Brewis and Review St. Louis. Digital Strategist by day, film/beer/hockey fanatic by night.

View Comments

  • I LOVED *MIRACLES*. It was a tremendous show and the chemistry between Angus McFadyen (Robert the Bruce in Braveheart) and Skeet Ulrich was amazing. Hector Elizondro was fantastic as well although his role was limited. I wish they would do a 3 part mini-series and wrap this one up -- I'm still left wondering --- is Paul good or bad? Is GOD NOW HERE, or is GOD NOWHERE?

    I disagree about Sunset though, I found it pretentious and somewhat condescending. The acting was forced and was too full of itself. Like everthing was due or die in every moment and the characters were unsympathetic. When you don't care about even one character on a show, it is tough to connect.

  • I agree with most of your choices. Particular favorites of mine are Firefly, Angel, Freaks and Geeks, and Studio 60. One not on your list was the ridiculously short lived Fox show Kitchen Confidential which it also killed with mismanagement. Why you would ever put on 2 episodes of a brand new show then preempt it for a month with a sporting event is beyond me, yet they kill at least 1 show every year that way.

  • Very glad to see Firefly at #1. I didn't know about the show until it had already been long canceled. I didn't know FOX aired it out of sequence until now. That upsets me.

  • I didn't watch Firefly when it originally aired. I happened to buy Serenity on a whim after it was released on DVD. It was fantastic. The movie did enough to characterize for this newcomer, but still feel like the extension of a Series. I lvoed it. And the Agent was just frightening. So I bought the Series on DVD and I loved that too. I loved Buffy. I could never get into Angel, until the fifth season. You are dead on regarding that. The Fifth Season was great and it was so disappointing to see it get the ax.

  • All I can say is thank god for DVDs of these series. I own 4 of these shows on your list and faithfully watched 2 others. I have the bad luck of getting into TV shows that are great but that don't last as long as they should. This year is no exception with the end of Pushing Daisies, Eli Stone and Life. Can I pick'em or what?!?!

    I have a toss up between Firefly and Freaks & Geeks as my favorite. Who'd thought Seth Rogen from F&G would become such a major Hollywood player?

  • Freaks and Geeks, Firefly, and Dead Like Me are definitely great picks. I still believe Deadwood could have gotten two more seasons but I also understand the 3 seasons it did got wrapped up somewhat. One choice though not mentioned that I would for sure is The Class. it was such a sweet show that people just never flocked to.

  • 1) Firefly
    2) The Dresden Files
    3) Blood Ties
    4) The Lone Gunmen
    5) Dark Angel
    6) Studio 60
    7) Veronica Mars

  • I agree on all of these! they where some of the best TV shows on television! Ive seen all of them named here except miracles...
    too bad they didin't continue..

    You have great taste that's for sure!

  • Miracles was my fav. show.. I am a big movie buff from Carry Grant to Hugh Grant but always get the shows i like shuch as Firefly,Angle and Miracles Cancled

Recent Posts

Concert Photos: Sum 41, The Interruptors and Joey Valence & Brae at The Factory

Sum 41 brought its 'Tour of the Setting Sum' Tour to The Factory on April…

1 week ago

Concert Photos: 311 at Grinders KC

Photos and Review by Ashley Strom. On April 20th, in Kansas City, music and cannabis…

1 week ago

Movie Review: “Abigail,” starring, Melissa Barrera, Alisha Weir

​The latest horror feature from creative team Matt Bettinelli-Olpin and Tyler Gillett (the duo behind…

2 weeks ago

Movie Review: THE MINISTRY OF UNGENTLEMANLY WARFARE Starring Henry Cavill, Alan Ritchson, Alex Pettyfer

It never dawned on me at the time, but despite Sherlock Holmes appearing onscreen more…

2 weeks ago

Oklahoma commission turns heel on AEW

AEW Women's Wrestler Nyla Rose is currently in the news, not because of the former…

2 weeks ago

Interview: WWE Superstar Liv Morgan talks meeting fans, the draft, traveling and more

In the world of WWE, one of the most popular female wrestlers at the moment…

2 weeks ago