Categories: LocalOff the Wall

Time Magazine Breastfeeding Cover (May 2012) Sparks Internet Debate

Time Magazine: "Are You Mom Enough?" Cover for the Upcoming Issue
Chances are that if you went on the internet yesterday, you have seen friends and colleagues abuzz about Time Magazine. Also, if you are human, you were probably on the internet yesterday. Therefor, you most likely know what I am talking about already.

Time Magazine released their upcoming cover for the May 21st issue, featuring a cover story on attachment parenting. But what sparked a debate across the internet was not as much the article as it was the controversial cover. The magazine shows a 26-year-old mother (Jamie Lynne Grumet) standing while breastfeeding her 3-year-old child, who climbed up on a chair to reach his mother’s breast.

The publication has raised a number of concerns, from whether or not it is appropriate to put the image on newsstands to should the mother be breastfeeding past 3. And of course, internet users everywhere have weighed in on the topic. Today.com held a poll about the cover, where 131,000 users weighed in. The results showed only 27% said “It’s great!” where a whopping 73% said “Eh, I don’t really want to see that.”

So with this much controversy, the question is: was it a success? I would say yes.

The May 21 issue doesn’t even come out for another week and a half, and it was become the number one searched term on Google. That’s not to mention all of the publicity they are getting on television, radio, social media and everywhere else. That’s what we call free marketing.

If you want to find out what they are actually talking about in the article, you can visit Time Magazine’s website. This is what you get:

The Man Who Remade Motherhood

Joanne Beauregard is nothing so much as she is a mother. When she and her husband had trouble conceiving, Joanne quit her job as an accountant to focus full time on getting pregnant. When she did, she chose to give birth at home, without pain medication. Then, for months, Beauregard sat on the couch in her Denver-area living room, nursing her infant from sunup to sundown. She nursed much of the night as well, since the baby slept in bed with Beauregard and her husband Daniel, a software engineer.
When Beauregard got pregnant with her second child, she continued breast-feeding her…

Source: time.com.

So basically nothing. You either have to buy an online subscription, or pick up the magazine from newsstands to figure out what the crazy cover is actually all about. Pretty genius if you ask me. So what does this mean for traditional media? I haven’t heard this much buzz about Time Magazine in… ever.

Here is video from the Today Show Friday, where Jamie Lynne Grumet defends her choice to be on the cover, as well as her attachment parenting techniques that landed her there:

What do you think about the cover? Is it appropriate to put on the shelves for all to see? Tell us in the comments below.

Kevin Brackett

Kevin Brackett is a professional film and theatre critic. He is also a member of the St. Louis Film Critics Association (SLFCA). Since founding Review St. Louis in 2008, he remains editor and operator of the online publication. Kevin is also a co-host of the Reel Spoilers podcast, and former National Vice President of the Technology Student Association (TSA), comprised of over 200,000 members worldwide. E-mail: kevin [at] reviewstl.com.

View Comments

  • As a family physician and breastfeeding specialist, I encourage mothers to nurse for as long as their child wants to continue, which is the physiologically normal way and proven to be beneficial not only for the child but also for the mother's health. In a country like the US, where about 25% of babies are never breastfed and the majority of those who are breastfed are weaned from the breast within months, fewer than 20% of children are nursing by one year of age. As a result of this abnormally high rate of premature weaning, the self-weaning that should naturally occur sometime between 2 1/2 years and 7 years of age based on anthropological studies, is seen as deviant behavior and labeled "extended nursing." Nursing for a few years and attachment parenting are not some new-fangled concoction but age-old, time-tested normal behaviors that were abandoned in the US during the 20th century. It's unfortunate, but maybe we need a jolt of reality from this type of sensationalistic photo just to get the issue discussed.

  • This will get all the pedophiles aroused. Way to go Times Magazine??!! Says something about our demented society.

Recent Posts

Movie Review: THE ODYSSEY starring Matt Damon, Tom Holland

Christopher Nolan has done it again. With The Odyssey, Nolan takes one of the oldest…

4 days ago

Movie Review: EVIL DEAD BURN starring Souheila Yacoub, Hunter Doohan

The deadites are back in the latest installment of the Evil Dead franchise in Sébastien Vaniček’s Evil Dead Burn. To say the…

1 week ago

Opera Review: ROMEO AND JULIET at OTSL

Cross words and crossed swords meet with tragic results in Opera Theatre of Saint Louis’ Romeo and Juliet. The…

1 month ago

Opera Review: A STREETCAR NAMED DESIRE at OTSL

Southern charm meets emotional harm in Opera Theatre of Saint Louis’ A Streetcar Named Desire,…

1 month ago

Opera Review: THE LIGHT IN THE PIAZZA at OTSL

Love is in the air in Florence, but not everyone is happy about it. This…

2 months ago

Movie Review: PRESSURE starring Andrew Scott, Brendan Fraser

Pressure is the kind of war film that succeeds not through explosions or battlefield spectacle,…

2 months ago