Theater Review: A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical at The Fabulous Fox

A popular trend on Broadway in recent years has been the jukebox musical, which takes an artist’s existing catalog of music and creates a musical theater production. Successful shows such as Jersey Boys and Beautiful: The Carole King Musical have artfully blended music and storytelling, creating a musical with meaningful character development while using well-loved songs to move the story forward. Unfortunately, A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical struggles to strike that same balance, often blurring the line between storytelling and a tribute concert.

A Beautiful Noise: The Neil Diamond Musical opens with a present-day Neil Diamond (an incredibly talented but woefully underutilized Stuart Metcalf) attending a therapy session. When his therapist struggles to get him to open up, she introduces an anthology of his songs. As Neil begins reflecting on his songwriting, the musical jumps back to the beginning of his career. The production rests almost entirely, and expertly, on the shoulders of the impressive Jesse Labelle as the younger Neil. Labelle’s portrayal is remarkably authentic, capturing Diamond’s distinctive voice and mannerisms. Claire Marshall brings a fun energy to her portrayal of Diamond’s second wife, Marcia Murphey, particularly during the second act (Forever in Blue Jeans).

The greatest challenge with A Beautiful Noise is that the book frequently gets in the way of the music. The production struggles to find a cohesive narrative as it shifts between an older Neil explaining the inspiration behind his songs, recreations of his concert performances, and musical numbers sung by supporting characters. The result is a disjointed production that never quite works. When the songs focus on the emotions of those surrounding Neil, his own thoughts and feelings become lost in the shuffle. Consequently, audiences are given little reason to invest in his personal journey, redemption, or the overall plot. Ultimately, the musical might have been better served by focusing on the extraordinary talents of its star, Labelle, and simply allowing him to sing for two hours.

That notwithstanding, the ensemble cast is undeniably talented, making the most of the limited material they are given. The choreography is simplistic, missing opportunities to showcase the performers’ considerable abilities. The costumes, however, are wonderfully done, filled with the sequins and glamour that defined the 1960/70s concert stages. Yet, the production shines brightest when the younger Neil takes center stage. Given the talent of the cast, this feels like a particularly unfortunate missed opportunity.

For fans of Neil Diamond, A Beautiful Noise offers an entertaining evening filled with his greatest songwriting hits but does not succeed to deliver on the real storytelling of his life. The production attempts to explore the deeper complexities of Diamond’s life, but it ultimately fails to develop his character and personal struggles enough. New fans of Neil Diamond’s music will delight in the memorable music and fantastic performances but won’t feel connected beyond the momentary excitement of the show.

Angela Fulbright

Recent Posts

Theater Review: BOOP! The Musical at The Fabulous Fox

Betty Boop is an iconic cartoon character of the 1930s, known for her signature voice,…

2 weeks ago

Theater Review: CLUE at The Fabulous Fox

Clue, originally known as Cluedo, was created in 1943 by British board game designer Anthony…

2 months ago

Jacob Fatu: Family, Second Chances and the Road to WWE

Inside a WWE ring, Jacob Fatu looks like a man who could come unhinged at…

2 months ago

Movie Review: HEART OF THE BEAST starring Brad Pitt, JK Simmons

Brad Pitt and director David Ayer team up once again in Heart of the Beast,…

2 months ago

Interview: WWE Superstar Raquel Rodriguez

Raquel Rodriguez has spent years establishing herself as one of the most powerful women in…

2 months ago