Rodgers & Hammerstein’s “South Pacific” at the Fox Theatre Will Leave You Speechless

Rodger and Hammerstein’s “South Pacific” opened at the Fox Theatre in St. Louis on Tuesday Night. After each number, there was seldom a time where applause did not flood the glorious 4,500 seat auditorium. Everything – from the magnificent sets, to the incredible singing voices – was simply perfect.

“South Pacific,” based on James Michener’s Pulitzer Prize winning book “Tales of the South Pacific,” is set on an island during World War II. The show tells the story of two blossoming romances taking place on the island. The first is between a Frenchman named Emile de Becque (David Pittsinger) who fled to the island from trouble back home, and a Navy nurse named Nellie Forbush (Carmen Cusack) who is stationed there. The second story belongs to Navy lieutenant Joe Cable (Anderson Davis) and a native girl named Liat (Sumie Maeda). The parallel story of both couples shows the the trials and tribulations of dealing with prejudice and the war going on. “South Pacific” combines some of Rodgers and Hammerstein’s best work with some of the best voices I’ve ever heard in a Broadway production to emotionally tell their stories.

David Pittsinger as Emile de Becque and Carmen Cusack as Nellie Forbush – photo by Craig Schwartz

The two main characters of the story, Emile and Nellie, are played by two actors with unbelievably stunning vocal abilities. From the moment that each of them opened their mouths and begin to sing, you could feel the entire audience awe struck. The deep, bass-baritone voice of veteran opera singer David Pittsinger is unlike anything I have heard in a recent production. With over 20 year of experience in opera houses around the world, Pittsinger is able to fill his first Broadway role with ease. Equally impressive is the beautifully classical voice of Carmen Cusack. The show is set in the 1940s, and I can not think of a more talented performer to turn back the clock for this show. With a sound that reminds me of Judy Garland or Julie Andrews, each time she sang was a delight.

After a beautiful overture, and hearing Emile de Becque’s children singing “Dites-Moi,” we are introduced to the first song that Nellie sings – “A Cockeyed Optimist.” The song is great, and sounds so smooth with Carmen at the helm. Then comes “Twin Soliloquies,” where both Emile and Nellie sing about their feelings for each other. The combination of the two of them singing together is intoxicating, as Pittsinger’s powerful voice is the perfect compliment to Cusack’s sweet sound.

Anderson Davis as Lt. Joseph Cable and Sumie Maeda as Liat – photo by Peter Coombs

We are introduced to lieutenant Cable around half-way through Act I. Just when you think there isn’t room on stage for more of the caliber of voices we’ve heard – here comes another. Anderson Davis has the perfect look for the role, with the sound to match. His character is cool, calm and collected – and that is exactly what Davis is. He owns the role, as he sings “My Girl Back Home” and “Younger Than Springtime” to name a couple.

Beside from the leads in the show, “South Pacific” is packed with a wonderful cast that really make the show a lot of fun. Bloody Mary (Jodi Kimura) introduces us to “Bali Ha’i” after Billis (Timothy Gulan) and the rest of the sailers teach us that “There is Nothing Like a Dame.” Gulan does a great job throughout the show as slick entrepreneur, who provides much of the comedic relief during the production. The singing and dancing from the rest of the sailers and ensemble is great as well.

“South Pacific” is a show that took until 2008 to be revived on Broadway, after it’s original run ended in 1949. But it was worth the wait, and there has never been better timing. So many of the topics are relevant, with our Country at war once again and with race being such a relevant topic. The songs are timeless, and translate just as well today as they would have almost 60 years ago. With an incredibly talented cast, possessing voices that set the bar for modern theatre, “South Pacific” is something you don’t want to miss.

The Company performs “There is Nothin’ Like a Dame” – photo by Peter Coombs


Rodgers & Hammerstein’s “South Pacific” will grace the Fox Theatre stage for 16 performances, November 9-21!

For more information and to purchase tickets, visit fabulousfox.com or MetroTix.com!

Kevin Brackett

Kevin Brackett is a professional film and theatre critic. He is also a member of the St. Louis Film Critics Association (SLFCA). Since founding Review St. Louis in 2008, he remains editor and operator of the online publication. Kevin is also a co-host of the Reel Spoilers podcast, and former National Vice President of the Technology Student Association (TSA), comprised of over 200,000 members worldwide. E-mail: kevin [at] reviewstl.com.

View Comments

  • Musically, I agree this was a good production of South Pacific. But why, Oh why did they alter the story by omitting some of the details? Sgt Billis' part, which is supposed to be the comic relief, is altered almost beyond recognition & abbreviated so much there is very little comedy & lot of his scenes make no sense to anyone who had not previously seen this musical. The scenery was generally good but the USO show's blinking perfectly placed lighting towers don't reflect the realities of putting on a hastily prepared show in a war zone in the 1940s (Look at some USO show TV footage from Afghanistan today to see how difficult it is). Also there is no reason for the inaccuracy of the military & nurses uniforms. Acting wise Jodi Kimuras was relatively bland & her voice did not give the impression of a south seas native. Anderson Davis was neither boyish nor innocent enough (& despite your review) is all wrong for the part. His initial stage appearance made him seem arrogant, the exact opposite of what the character calls for (please remember this is the 1940s. And above all I hope you're wrong about him being the best Lt. Cable available today. Because if that's true there is a something wrong with the modern musical theatre). However, Carmen Cusack was very good (I like her better than Mary Martin) & David Pittsinger was truly magnificent. The best Emile ever. (Pinza was on the down side of his career when he took the part, although he was still enchanting). Overall I did enjoy the show but these flaws irritate because they could have & should been avoided even there are fewer people each year who are sufficiently acquainted with the show to recognize these faults.

Recent Posts

Movie Review: THE FALL GUY Starring Ryan Gosling, Emily Blunt, Aaron Taylor-Johnson

Real quick, think of the last good action movie you watched. Who was in it?…

1 day ago

Concert Photos: Joe Satriani and Steve Vai at The Factory

The Satch/Vai tour made a stop at a packed Factory on Tuesday evening. Photos by…

2 days ago

Comedy Review: Nikki Glaser laughs it up at The Fox Theatre

STL’s own Nikki Glaser performed at the Fox Theatre Saturday night as a stop on…

5 days ago

Concert Photos: Greta Van Fleet rocks out at Chaifetz Arena

Rock band Greta Van Fleet played to a sold-out crowd at Chaifetz Arena on Saturday…

5 days ago

Concert Photos: Cypress Hill with Souls of Mischief and The Pharcyde at Uptown Theater

Legendary hip-hop group Cypress Hill made a stop at The Uptown Theater in Kansas City…

5 days ago

Concert Photos: Silversun Pickups with Rocket at The Hawthorn

The Silversun Pickups tour made a stop at The Hawthorn in St. Louis on April…

6 days ago