Categories: Movie Reviews

Movie Review: ‘Can You Ever Forgive Me?’ Starring Melissa McCarthy, Richard E. Grant

Melissa McCarthy has made a nice career for herself playing a bumbling idiot in many hit comedies such as “Life of the Party,” “Tammy,” and “The Boss.” While critical bombs, these films still resided well with her fans.

Perhaps McCarthy has grown tired of playing the fool, as she has struck gold in her new film “Can You Ever Forgive Me?” McCarthy’s new film is based on a true story of real-life forger Lee Isreal. The film is based on Isreal’s 2008 memoir.

Isreal is a once-promising author who is down on her luck and looking to pay the bills, so she turns to literary forgery. She is also a mean, nasty New Yorker, which McCarthy plays perfectly. McCarthy’s performance is nothing short of extraordinary. She will undoubtedly get a lot of award-buzz come Oscar and Golden Globe time and rightfully so. Next to Rami Malek’s performance as Freddie Mercury, McCarthy turns in one of the finest performances of the year and the best of her career, showcasing her depth as an actress.

After losing her job at The New Yorker, Israel turns to forgery after meeting  John Hock, played by Richard E. Grant, who is also wonderful in the film. Israel finds that she has a knack for creating letters from dead authors, which she recognizes as some of her best work.

The tormented, angry Israel admits she has no friends and doesn’t even like people. In fact, her only friend seems to be her cat.

Without giving too much of this enjoyable film away, moviegoers will find themselves in awe of McCarthy’s stunning, yet immensely entertaining role as Lee Israel.

While Israel is now gone, having passed away in 2014, “Can You Ever Forgive Me?” is a look at a time when life in Manhattan was a bit more simple. It was back in a time when journalists were all over the city and small, independent bookstores filled the streets of New York. The film comes off as almost an ode to the city back in easier times, back then things weren’t so complicated.

“Can You Ever Forgive Me?” gets an A-.

Jeremy Housewright

Jeremy has been a journalist in the St. Louis area since 2000. He has covered everything from hard news and pro sports to movies and concerts. In his free time he enjoys writing movie reviews, watching professional wrestling and MMA, as well as being an avid football fan. Jeremy is a regular contributor to Review St. Louis, as well as his own sports website: clubhousetalk.com.

Recent Posts

Great Britten! A MIDSUMMER NIGHT’S DREAM Closes OTSL’s 50th Season (Review)

Opera Theatre of St. Louis' latest production is putting people to sleep. Literally. Fortunately, those…

2 weeks ago

Opera Review: Money, Mishaps and Marriage Fuel OTSL’s Hilarious DON PASQUALE

One of the ways that Opera Theatre of St. Louis is celebrating their 50th anniversary…

3 weeks ago

Opera Review: THIS HOUSE World Premiere at OSTL

This House, Opera Theatre of St. Louis’ 44th world premiere, proves that sometimes you shouldn’t…

4 weeks ago

A Perfect Circle, Puscifer and Primus members take audience for a ride at Hollywood Casino Amphitheater

By Jerry McGrath Be...Present.   Marked words to open the concert.   Maynard, in typical fashion, addresses…

4 weeks ago

Movie Review: KARATE KID: LEGENDS Starring Ben Wang, Jackie Chan, Ralph Macchio

Often times, legacy sequels strain under the weight of nostalgia. But Karate Kid: Legends wears…

1 month ago

Theater Review: Buffoonery Meets Bubbly With OTSL’s DIE FLEDERMAUS

To celebrate its 50th season Opera Theatre of St. Louis didn’t just uncork a bottle…

1 month ago